0 0 0This achievement is missable and can only be done in the Prelude, right at the beginning. After unlocking the outhouse door with the key, return the pegleg to the Scurvydog Shack, it's as simple as that.Pegleg Achievement:
0 0 0In the prelude chapter when you are playing as Guybrush's son. Go into the Scurvy Dog shop and pick up the peg leg with a key on it. Go back outside and into the toilet. Once inside, pick up the fake piece of eight. Return to the Scurvy Dog shop and place the peg leg back where you found it.