Here is the full list of all 18 Tape to Tape achievements.
Buy all superstars
Max Angus attributes
Win act 3
Register 40 shots in the same game
Win act 2
Win act 1
All opposing players are knocked on the ice.
Win an elite game with the mercy rule
Perform a Hat Trick
Win a game versus an elite team
Hit 5 players with your tomahawk
Complete the tutorial
Win the game with every character
Buy all skills
Score a goal with the headshot redirect
Score a goal with the yo-yo
Grow Gawain
Every player score 1 goal