Here is the full list of all 18 Tape to Tape achievements.
Win the game with every character
Grow Gawain
Max Angus attributes
Buy all superstars
All opposing players are knocked on the ice.
Buy all skills
Score a goal with the headshot redirect
Score a goal with the yo-yo
Win act 3
Win act 2
Every player score 1 goal
Register 40 shots in the same game
Win act 1
Win an elite game with the mercy rule
Perform a Hat Trick
Win a game versus an elite team
Hit 5 players with your tomahawk
Complete the tutorial