Here is the full list of all 20 Pony Island achievements. It takes around 4-5 hours to unlock all of the achievements on Windows.
Learned every secret of your past.
Found all 24 tickets.
Found Missingno.
Found the hidden profile screen.
Found 14 tickets.
Found 7 tickets.
Found an alternate avatar.
Learned a third secret of your past.
Learned another secret of your past.
Destroyed the third Core File.
Escaped the arcade.
Killed Louey.
Destroyed the second Core File.
Unlocked Pony Wings.
Destroyed the first Core File.
Unlocked Pony Lasers.
Found 3 tickets.
Learned a secret of your past.
Crashed the game.
Found your first ticket.