Here is the full list of all 75 Love Sucks: Night Two achievements.
Give Naomi a gift at the end of the night
Jan got Anna out of there
Chose to be a super villain
Make it through having Jan and Anna under the table
Sat down with Anna and learn a little more about her
Learn more about Jan by simply talking to her
The magic of having a heart-to-heart
The magic in sharing in a moment of genuine joy
Use death to cheat at a carnival game
A smoke bomb got Anna out of there
You can pet the dog in Love Sucks
Saved the pumpkin when eating out Jan in the Greenhouse
You need a burger, not more sex
Blow off Naomi and go with the girls
Survived Night Two
There's no reason to choose
The magic in defeating a rival together
Cum hard
The magic of making a display of trust
Mess around with Jan in a hall of mirrors
The magic of fourth base
Carve the greatest pumpkin ever carved
Get your photo taken at the cowboy booth
The magic of crating a lasting memento
Don't put your dick in that
Used death as an opportunity to help someone
The magic in helping with a secret desire
The magic in being true to one's self
Witness a Nimrod at work
The clear magic of Naomi's influence
Butter is a dairy product made from the fat and protein components of churned cream
Doing that in public was a moment for sure
Win a sharp and shiny prize at the Midway
The magic in giving a genuine gift to an appreciative recipient
Achieve a new high score in BBS with Anna
The magic in overcoming a challenge
Jan couldn't help herself
The magic of impressing your dates
Had a drink with Anna
69ing a succubus is definitely a magical moment
Enjoyed the Ferris Wheel with Jan
Partook in butt stuff. Have a rune
Witnessed a lewd and tender moment
Being Sexy got Anna out of there
The magic of helping someone out of a difficult situation
Similacrum Simulated
Angered Naomi by picking something crazy as the keyphrase
Destroyed the pumpkin when eating out Jan in the Greenhouse
Escaped the Greenhouse with Jan while Anna ran a distraction
Chose to be a mad scientist
Recruited a Witch to help
Met the real Sammy
Ate Naomi's burrito
Prayed at an Altar
Learned something about the world
It fell apart quickly...
Wait, what?
You're alive aren't you?
Don't stop
They make them this big?
Met a Not-Ghost
No glove, no love
Survive time with Jan
Anna gave you something back
You fixed it
Finished the night with Anna
Finished the night with Jan
Survived Night One
Escaped the Greenhouse with Anna while Jan ran a distraction
Spicy chips got Anna out of there
Destroy the lazy balloon and confound a carnie
Get your fortune told
Tied someone up, kind of
Anna got lost in passion. It was still worth it.
Layering just a little more magic couldn't hurt