In order to unlock this achievement you have to finish all the Domino games. To do so, when the HOB puzzle starts , press those three domino pieces in the bottom left corner to switch from HOB puzzle mode to Domino game. Then complete it.
Be aware that there are 17 games in the main game and 5 of them in additional chapter "The Abyss".
One more thing to mention! You can't get this achievement and the one for completing all the HOB puzzles in same play-through, so be SURE to always press that "switch to domino" button once HOB puzzle starts. Otherwise you'll have to complete the game two more times, which is doubtful pleasure...